The Curriculum Index

Every EF curriculum a school might buy — graded.

The Provider Index ranks people. This ranks programs — the executive-function curricula, screeners, and training packages that schools and districts actually purchase. Same weighted methodology. Same neutral posture.

The methodology

How each curriculum is scored.

Weight · 40%

Evidence base

Peer-reviewed effect sizes, replication studies, and the depth of the theoretical foundation. Curricula with public research bases score higher than proprietary ones with vendor-run trials.

Weight · 25%

Family / classroom fit

Does it survive contact with a real second-grade classroom or a Tuesday-night homework session? Programs that require ideal conditions to work are scored down.

Weight · 20%

Cost transparency

Public per-seat or per-site pricing scores higher than opaque enterprise contracts. Free public-research curricula (SRSD, Executive Skills Questionnaire) get the ceiling.

Weight · 15%

Ongoing use

Adoption depth, not adoption breadth. Schools that renew year over year matter more than a big pilot cohort that quietly disappears.

The ranked index

18 EF curricula, graded A through C.

Updated quarterly. Add a curriculum for review at contact.html. Life Lifted takes no vendor money — every grade is independent.

Rank Curriculum EF Domain Grade Band Grade Score Cost
#01 Executive Skills in Children & Adolescents (Dawson & Guare)
The clinical bible. Not a curriculum per se — the foundational text most other curricula reference.
General EF K–12 A+ 96 $45/book
#02 SMARTS
Research-backed EF curriculum from Research ILD. Middle/high school gold standard. Real training required.
Planning & Organization 6–12 A 93 $1,850/site
#03 Self-Regulated Strategy Development (SRSD)
Best-in-class for writing initiation. Public-domain research base. Underused.
Task Initiation / Planning 3–12 A 92 Free (public research)
#04 Zones of Regulation
The most widely-adopted classroom EF curriculum. Strong on emotional-regulation vocabulary. Weak on transfer to home.
Emotional Regulation K–8 A- 91 $149/school
#05 Executive Skills Questionnaire (Dawson-Guare)
Not a curriculum — the standard screener. Every school should be running it. Most aren't.
Assessment K–12 A 90 Free
#06 Superflex & the Unthinkables
Social Thinking's flagship. Excellent character-based framework kids remember. Requires trained facilitator for best results.
Cognitive Flexibility K–5 A- 89 $220/school
#07 Learning to Plan (Meltzer)
Strategy-instruction focus. Best for kids who can read but can't sequence.
Planning & Prioritizing 3–8 A- 89 $220/set
#08 PATHS Program
Deep clinical evidence base. Excellent for early elementary. Onboarding is a lift.
Emotional Regulation K–6 A- 88 $795/kit
#09 Cognitive Coaching (Costa & Garmston)
For teachers, not students. Reshapes how educators talk about thinking. High-leverage staff investment.
Cognitive Flexibility Staff A- 87 $3,200/cohort
#10 Executive Function 101 (Cook)
Rebecca Branstetter's classroom guide. Practical, teacher-friendly. Not a full program.
General EF 3–12 B+ 84 $65/book
#11 Executive Function Coaching Certification (Beyond Booksmart)
Private-tutor certification. Real methodology. Vendor-locked.
Coaching Staff B+ 84 $4,900/cert
#12 The Incredible 5-Point Scale
Buron & Curtis's scale-based regulation tool. Cheap, effective, adopted at scale.
Emotional Regulation K–8 B+ 83 $18/book
#13 Second Step
Broad SEL program with EF-adjacent content. Strong district infrastructure. Not EF-primary.
Emotional Regulation K–8 B+ 82 $319/grade
#14 MindUP
SEL curriculum with mindfulness base. Broad adoption. EF-adjacent.
Emotional Regulation K–8 B 79 $249/grade
#15 Mindful Schools
Mindfulness curriculum with EF halo. Evidence base is real but modest for EF specifically.
Emotional Regulation / Attention K–12 B 78 $495/course
#16 Attention Improvement Program (Cogmed)
Computerized working-memory training. Real gains in-task, weak transfer to classroom.
Working Memory K–adult B 76 $1,595/user
#17 Brain Highways
Popular in some pockets. Evidence base is thin. Life Lifted does not currently recommend.
Sensory / EF hybrid K–8 C+ 68 $3,400/family
#18 Kelso's Choice
Elementary conflict resolution. EF-adjacent, not EF-primary.
Conflict / Regulation K–5 C+ 66 $149/kit
A note on grades

What A, B, and C actually mean.

A / A+ / A- — Life Lifted actively recommends. Evidence base is strong; classroom fit is proven; the vendor is honest about what the program can and cannot do.

B+ / B / B- — Situationally useful. Works well when paired with the right infrastructure. Worth considering, not automatic.

C+ / C / C- — Life Lifted does not currently recommend. Evidence is thin, cost is high relative to alternatives, or the vendor claims exceed the demonstrated results.