The Provider Index ranks people. This ranks programs — the executive-function curricula, screeners, and training packages that schools and districts actually purchase. Same weighted methodology. Same neutral posture.
Peer-reviewed effect sizes, replication studies, and the depth of the theoretical foundation. Curricula with public research bases score higher than proprietary ones with vendor-run trials.
Does it survive contact with a real second-grade classroom or a Tuesday-night homework session? Programs that require ideal conditions to work are scored down.
Public per-seat or per-site pricing scores higher than opaque enterprise contracts. Free public-research curricula (SRSD, Executive Skills Questionnaire) get the ceiling.
Adoption depth, not adoption breadth. Schools that renew year over year matter more than a big pilot cohort that quietly disappears.
Updated quarterly. Add a curriculum for review at contact.html. Life Lifted takes no vendor money — every grade is independent.
| Rank | Curriculum | EF Domain | Grade Band | Grade | Score | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #01 | Executive Skills in Children & Adolescents (Dawson & Guare) The clinical bible. Not a curriculum per se — the foundational text most other curricula reference. |
General EF | K–12 | A+ | 96 | $45/book |
| #02 | SMARTS Research-backed EF curriculum from Research ILD. Middle/high school gold standard. Real training required. |
Planning & Organization | 6–12 | A | 93 | $1,850/site |
| #03 | Self-Regulated Strategy Development (SRSD) Best-in-class for writing initiation. Public-domain research base. Underused. |
Task Initiation / Planning | 3–12 | A | 92 | Free (public research) |
| #04 | Zones of Regulation The most widely-adopted classroom EF curriculum. Strong on emotional-regulation vocabulary. Weak on transfer to home. |
Emotional Regulation | K–8 | A- | 91 | $149/school |
| #05 | Executive Skills Questionnaire (Dawson-Guare) Not a curriculum — the standard screener. Every school should be running it. Most aren't. |
Assessment | K–12 | A | 90 | Free |
| #06 | Superflex & the Unthinkables Social Thinking's flagship. Excellent character-based framework kids remember. Requires trained facilitator for best results. |
Cognitive Flexibility | K–5 | A- | 89 | $220/school |
| #07 | Learning to Plan (Meltzer) Strategy-instruction focus. Best for kids who can read but can't sequence. |
Planning & Prioritizing | 3–8 | A- | 89 | $220/set |
| #08 | PATHS Program Deep clinical evidence base. Excellent for early elementary. Onboarding is a lift. |
Emotional Regulation | K–6 | A- | 88 | $795/kit |
| #09 | Cognitive Coaching (Costa & Garmston) For teachers, not students. Reshapes how educators talk about thinking. High-leverage staff investment. |
Cognitive Flexibility | Staff | A- | 87 | $3,200/cohort |
| #10 | Executive Function 101 (Cook) Rebecca Branstetter's classroom guide. Practical, teacher-friendly. Not a full program. |
General EF | 3–12 | B+ | 84 | $65/book |
| #11 | Executive Function Coaching Certification (Beyond Booksmart) Private-tutor certification. Real methodology. Vendor-locked. |
Coaching | Staff | B+ | 84 | $4,900/cert |
| #12 | The Incredible 5-Point Scale Buron & Curtis's scale-based regulation tool. Cheap, effective, adopted at scale. |
Emotional Regulation | K–8 | B+ | 83 | $18/book |
| #13 | Second Step Broad SEL program with EF-adjacent content. Strong district infrastructure. Not EF-primary. |
Emotional Regulation | K–8 | B+ | 82 | $319/grade |
| #14 | MindUP SEL curriculum with mindfulness base. Broad adoption. EF-adjacent. |
Emotional Regulation | K–8 | B | 79 | $249/grade |
| #15 | Mindful Schools Mindfulness curriculum with EF halo. Evidence base is real but modest for EF specifically. |
Emotional Regulation / Attention | K–12 | B | 78 | $495/course |
| #16 | Attention Improvement Program (Cogmed) Computerized working-memory training. Real gains in-task, weak transfer to classroom. |
Working Memory | K–adult | B | 76 | $1,595/user |
| #17 | Brain Highways Popular in some pockets. Evidence base is thin. Life Lifted does not currently recommend. |
Sensory / EF hybrid | K–8 | C+ | 68 | $3,400/family |
| #18 | Kelso's Choice Elementary conflict resolution. EF-adjacent, not EF-primary. |
Conflict / Regulation | K–5 | C+ | 66 | $149/kit |
A / A+ / A- — Life Lifted actively recommends. Evidence base is strong; classroom fit is proven; the vendor is honest about what the program can and cannot do.
B+ / B / B- — Situationally useful. Works well when paired with the right infrastructure. Worth considering, not automatic.
C+ / C / C- — Life Lifted does not currently recommend. Evidence is thin, cost is high relative to alternatives, or the vendor claims exceed the demonstrated results.